Copyright Practices


The issue of copyright ownership is frequently raised in the course of normal use of collection materials. The vast majority of content in the archives was not produced by Spec and therefore original copyright does not lie with the department. In limited cases copyrights may have been formally transferred to Spec by the donor. Additionally, some material may not reside in the public domain based upon its age. In all cases, Spec representatives should proceed cautiously when a patron asks for rights to reproduce materials for any purpose other than those listed under the fair use clause of copyright law1. Patrons should be instructed that it is their personal responsibility to locate the copyright owner and secure permissions to reproduce any materials gathered from Spec in the course of their research.

For materials originally produced by the University of Idaho or an employee in the course of their work, a formal request for approval to reproduce should be submitted through the Office of Technology Transfer.

When reproductions of materials are provided to a patron, the following language should accompany the transfer, in email, in a digital document included in the transfer file or flash drive, or as a printed note along with physical copies.

The legal exception of Fair Use under copyright law allows for the reproduction of copyrighted works under certain conditions. In general, patron requests can be judged against the following criteria.

MORE LIKELY to be Fair Use:

Content adapted from Amy Dygent, "Copyright services and the university," Society of American Archivists Annual Meeting 2020.

Purpose & Character of Use If the work created is:
  • Educational
  • Transformative
  • Non-profit
Purpose & Character of Original Material If the archival material used is:
  • Factual
  • Non-fiction
  • News
  • Published
Amount of Original Material Used If intended to take from original material:
  • A small amount
  • Only as much as necessary
Effect of Use on Potential Market If:
  • Use has no significant effect on the market
  • Few copies of work are made/distributed
  • Access to work is restricted (to class use, to private server, etc.)
  • Original work is no longer sold, in print, or distrusted

LESS LIKELY to be Fair Use:

Content adapted from Amy Dygent, "Copyright services and the university," Society of American Archivists Annual Meeting 2020.

Purpose & Character of Use If the work created is:
  • Commercial entertainment
  • Verbatim (untransformed)
  • From original
  • Profit-generating
Purpose & Character of Original Material If the archival material used is:
  • Creative
  • Fiction
  • Entertainment
  • Unpublished
Amount of Original Material Used If intended to take from original material:
  • A large amount or entire work
  • More than necessary for educational purposes
Effect of Use on Potential Market If:
  • Work prevents sales of original
  • Work is made broadly available to public
  • Access to work is restricted (to class use, to private server, etc.)
  • Owner/creator of original work requests that users license the material

Footnotes

  1. “Fair use is a legal doctrine that promotes freedom of expression by permitting the unlicensed use of copyright-protected works in certain circumstances. Section 107 of the Copyright Act provides the statutory framework for determining whether something is a fair use and identifies certain types of uses—such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research—as examples of activities that may qualify as fair use.” Sourced from https://www.copyright.gov/fair-use/ on Sep. 29, 2022.